Salary and director fees: PAYE follows the directorship
The rule that surprises people is that fees for a UK directorship are taxed by reference to where the company is, not where you sit. So the UK taxes them, the company must operate PAYE on them, and the short-term business visitor arrangements that protect many visiting employees specifically exclude directors. There is relief at the edges: where you also do genuinely separate operational work abroad, earnings can usually be apportioned by days, with the company notifying HMRC under section 690 so PAYE only bites on the UK-duties slice and the final position is settled through Self Assessment. British and EEA nationals, and residents of many treaty countries, can still claim the £12,570 personal allowance against this income. Our non-resident director guide works through the apportionment in detail.
Dividends: no withholding, and often little or no UK tax
A UK company pays dividends gross, with no UK withholding tax. For a non-resident, UK dividends are disregarded income: your total UK liability is broadly capped at the tax on your non-disregarded UK income (such as rent or director fees) worked out without the personal allowance. Because nothing was deducted at source from the dividend, the practical effect is often no extra UK tax on it at all. The trade-off is that invoking the cap costs you the personal allowance elsewhere, so you compare two calculations and take the better one. Your home country will usually tax the dividend under its own rules with credit rather than exemption, which is where double tax relief comes in.
The pieces that decide the mix
Four things move the answer. National Insurance: without a certificate of coverage or HMRC's narrow board-meeting concession, salary can attract employee NIC at 8% and employer NIC at 15% that dividends never do. Corporation tax: salary is deductible for the company, dividends are not, so the comparison is never just personal. Company residence: if board decisions are genuinely being taken abroad, central management and control can put the company itself in play, which is worth checking before it becomes a problem. And your home country: an extraction that looks efficient in the UK can be undone by how the other country taxes salary versus dividends. Running a UK company from abroad raises all four at once. We solve exactly this two-country sum for overseas directors on a fixed fee agreed before any work starts, and a free 30-minute clarity call is the easiest way to scope it.
